I was supposed to have the follow-up appointment with my new neurologist today. I've completed all but one of the new battery of tests she ordered and was looking forward to hearing her assessment of what she can do about my auto-immune disorders.
Only, she called in sick.
I'm worried about her, as she was away on sick leave for months. I hope this is just a virus and not related to her extended leave. So, I wish her well and look forward to getting the call about rescheduling.
Meanwhile, I remain in limbo. Having finally seen her, after a year of trying, my anxiety level had gone down somewhat. I had a modicum of cautious hope. I can feel the anxiety creeping back in now. I hope I get a new appointment soon.
Its all such a long and painful process.
Wednesday, March 17, 2010
Tuesday, March 16, 2010
Why Are We Being Denied?
Whenever the IDSA guideline proponents argue against the right of doctors to treat their patients as they see fit, they seem to most commonly express concern about the dangers of intravenous antibiotics. I haven't heard any other reason for which they are willing to deny care to patients and to testify against fellow doctors for treating those patient. From their own report on the guidelines review hearings last summer:
As I've said before, I'm not a fan of antibiotics. I've yet to be convinced that they are the right treatment for Lyme Disease. Though, I must admit, that in my history with the illness, thus far, I have seen the most sustainable improvement when I was getting injected antibiotics for approximately a year. I was not cured, but I was definitely improved. And I definitely declined symptomatically once the antibiotics were stopped because Harvard Pilgrim Health Care retroactively denied coverage of my treatment. (Is that legal, by the way? To demand to be repaid for a year's worth of treatment which they had already paid for?)
There may well be other, better treatments out there, but since the IDSA has been allowed to disproportionately influence the entire medical community regarding Lyme Disease, no one is researching treatment because the IDSA denies that any treatment is needed. Therefore, it is the only option being offered to people who suffer long-term from Lyme. Since the objection to allowing this treatment is such a strong concern for the deleterious effects and grave risks, let's just consider this claim about the "dangers" and "complications" of longer-term antibiotics.
Here's a recent study on the subject:
This group studied 200 patients with neurologic Lyme Disease who received intravenous antibiotics for a mean duration of 188 days (a total of 23,654 IVD-days.) A summary of the results:
Now, I don't want to be that 1 person with the gallbladder toxicity. Allergic reactions are no fun, either. Nor is an incidental infection. Still, I've been suffering for 5 years. I can't hold a job due to cognitive unreliability and unrelenting fatigue. The risks my father took with cancer treatments were far more significant and no one balked at him or his doctors for giving them a try. As a patient, I am very comfortable with the risks seen here. These seem like pretty good odds to face for the chance of getting my health back. Indeed, here is the study's conclusion:
Tell me again. What exactly is the IDSA's scientific and compassionate reason for tyrannically denying me the opportunity for treatment?
The panel heard from some of the authors of IDSA’s guidelines, who concluded there is no convincing biologic evidence for symptomatic, chronic Borrelia burgdorferi infection after completion of the recommended treatment for Lyme disease, which, according to IDSA’s guidelines, is 10-28 days, depending on the stage of illness. Longer-term antibiotics may be dangerous and can lead to complications, according to IDSA.A short note on the misleading statement about "no convincing biologic evidence": Its a red herring. Not only is there evidence, they have never proven that chronic infection cannot be possible. When denying people treatment, don't you have the burden of proof here?
As I've said before, I'm not a fan of antibiotics. I've yet to be convinced that they are the right treatment for Lyme Disease. Though, I must admit, that in my history with the illness, thus far, I have seen the most sustainable improvement when I was getting injected antibiotics for approximately a year. I was not cured, but I was definitely improved. And I definitely declined symptomatically once the antibiotics were stopped because Harvard Pilgrim Health Care retroactively denied coverage of my treatment. (Is that legal, by the way? To demand to be repaid for a year's worth of treatment which they had already paid for?)
There may well be other, better treatments out there, but since the IDSA has been allowed to disproportionately influence the entire medical community regarding Lyme Disease, no one is researching treatment because the IDSA denies that any treatment is needed. Therefore, it is the only option being offered to people who suffer long-term from Lyme. Since the objection to allowing this treatment is such a strong concern for the deleterious effects and grave risks, let's just consider this claim about the "dangers" and "complications" of longer-term antibiotics.
Here's a recent study on the subject:
Safety of intravenous antibiotic therapy in patients referred for treatment of neurologic Lyme disease
This group studied 200 patients with neurologic Lyme Disease who received intravenous antibiotics for a mean duration of 188 days (a total of 23,654 IVD-days.) A summary of the results:
- no one died
- 3.5% experienced allergic reactions to the antibiotic
- 1.0% had gallbladder toxicity
- IVD complications occurred in 15 patients (7.5%)
- IVD complications represented an incidence of 0.63 per 1,000 IVD-days
- 6 suspected line infections for an incidence of 0.25 per 1,000 IVD-days.
- Only one of the IVD infections was confirmed
- resistant organisms were cultured from any patient.
Now, I don't want to be that 1 person with the gallbladder toxicity. Allergic reactions are no fun, either. Nor is an incidental infection. Still, I've been suffering for 5 years. I can't hold a job due to cognitive unreliability and unrelenting fatigue. The risks my father took with cancer treatments were far more significant and no one balked at him or his doctors for giving them a try. As a patient, I am very comfortable with the risks seen here. These seem like pretty good odds to face for the chance of getting my health back. Indeed, here is the study's conclusion:
CONCLUSION: Prolonged intravenous antibiotic therapy is associated with low morbidity and no IVD-related mortality in patients referred for treatment of neurologic Lyme disease. With proper IVD care, the risk of extended antibiotic therapy in these patients appears to be low.
Tell me again. What exactly is the IDSA's scientific and compassionate reason for tyrannically denying me the opportunity for treatment?
Thursday, March 11, 2010
Mourning Mornings
I've been struggling with this illness for at least 5 years now. As my sensitivity to sound, light, smells, and motion worsen, I definitely have acute episodes of extreme discomfort. These sensory issues, along with the cognitive losses, are far more debilitating to me than any of the pains in my joints or the tingling/burning/numbness in my extremities. Feeling assaulted by the normal input of the world and not being able to think properly create cycles of despair and loneliness. Though, it is usually later in the day that I have to shut down from the overload, its is the mornings which wear me down emotionally the most.
For the first 42 years of my life, I was an excellent sleeper. I put my head down on the pillow and within minutes I was asleep. Eight hours later, I would awake refreshed and energized for a new day. When I went skiing with friends, I was often the first up on the slopes. When I did some programming for a health club, I taught a 6am aerobics class to get the day going. I might have phases of being a night owl, but I still slept 8 hours, ready to hit whatever road lay ahead for that day when I awoke.
Now, waking up is a chore in and of itself. The first thing I notice is that my ears are already screeching and they are filled with the roar of things going on outside and inside my house. Next, it is the pain in my feet. Sharp pains. As though someone has run a knife along the underside of my toes right where they meet the balls of my feet, and another slice across the middle of my soles, feeling as if the tendon in my arch has been severed.
Then I assess the level of the tingling/burning sensations. Is it just to my ankles? Can I feel it in my calves? Is it up past my knees? What about my hands? Can I feel them? Can I move them? Do they feel swollen? How bad is the ache in my elbows? My hips? My shoulders? How stiff is my neck? Do I have a headache? How's my face? Are my lips tingling? Is my face puffy? Can I feel my face?
Worst of all: can I fully wake up? Are my eyes open? Sometimes I can't see for a while, so I have to check if my eyes are open. Other times, I just see a world behind a waterfall. There are things there, but I can't quite make them out. Can I lift my head off the pillow? If I try to move, will my body actuate the commands from my brain? Its hard to explain this inability to waken. I lie there, hearing all that is going on around me, but it feels as if I'm in a coma. I can't quite break free of the sleep state. Some days this may just be minutes. Others it is hours. I focus on breathing. I can't say I get panicked any longer. I used to panic. It simply made things worse. Now I stay calm and try to breathe through as much as I can while I wait it out. There is no point in pushing myself too hard. If I even made it upright and started walking, I wouldn't make it down the stairs.
I suppose if I didn't have people I care for, interests in life, or things I want to do, I wouldn't care. I could just wile away my days, lingering in bed. However, that's not me. Perhaps, I would have been better off with different cognitive impairments. I have horrible short-term memory and attention problems now, but my intellect is still fairly keen. My imagination is in tact. I have an active but unmanageable brain. I need a personal assistant to keep me on task. I've always had an active brain. I have never been bored in my life. I always find things of interest to pursue. I once realized that if I were locked away in a cell with nothing to do, I'd probably write a novel in my head and then start on other creative pursuits. So, here's the thing: I have things I want to pursue. I want to get out of bed and get going. For me, nothing is more deflating than the fact that I can't.
Day after day after day. Months on end. Years gone by. My mornings are not what they once were. Sometimes they are not at all. Mornings have given over to mourning. Mourning the person I once was. The life I was once living. The world I was once enthralled with.
For the first 42 years of my life, I was an excellent sleeper. I put my head down on the pillow and within minutes I was asleep. Eight hours later, I would awake refreshed and energized for a new day. When I went skiing with friends, I was often the first up on the slopes. When I did some programming for a health club, I taught a 6am aerobics class to get the day going. I might have phases of being a night owl, but I still slept 8 hours, ready to hit whatever road lay ahead for that day when I awoke.
Now, waking up is a chore in and of itself. The first thing I notice is that my ears are already screeching and they are filled with the roar of things going on outside and inside my house. Next, it is the pain in my feet. Sharp pains. As though someone has run a knife along the underside of my toes right where they meet the balls of my feet, and another slice across the middle of my soles, feeling as if the tendon in my arch has been severed.
Then I assess the level of the tingling/burning sensations. Is it just to my ankles? Can I feel it in my calves? Is it up past my knees? What about my hands? Can I feel them? Can I move them? Do they feel swollen? How bad is the ache in my elbows? My hips? My shoulders? How stiff is my neck? Do I have a headache? How's my face? Are my lips tingling? Is my face puffy? Can I feel my face?
Worst of all: can I fully wake up? Are my eyes open? Sometimes I can't see for a while, so I have to check if my eyes are open. Other times, I just see a world behind a waterfall. There are things there, but I can't quite make them out. Can I lift my head off the pillow? If I try to move, will my body actuate the commands from my brain? Its hard to explain this inability to waken. I lie there, hearing all that is going on around me, but it feels as if I'm in a coma. I can't quite break free of the sleep state. Some days this may just be minutes. Others it is hours. I focus on breathing. I can't say I get panicked any longer. I used to panic. It simply made things worse. Now I stay calm and try to breathe through as much as I can while I wait it out. There is no point in pushing myself too hard. If I even made it upright and started walking, I wouldn't make it down the stairs.
I suppose if I didn't have people I care for, interests in life, or things I want to do, I wouldn't care. I could just wile away my days, lingering in bed. However, that's not me. Perhaps, I would have been better off with different cognitive impairments. I have horrible short-term memory and attention problems now, but my intellect is still fairly keen. My imagination is in tact. I have an active but unmanageable brain. I need a personal assistant to keep me on task. I've always had an active brain. I have never been bored in my life. I always find things of interest to pursue. I once realized that if I were locked away in a cell with nothing to do, I'd probably write a novel in my head and then start on other creative pursuits. So, here's the thing: I have things I want to pursue. I want to get out of bed and get going. For me, nothing is more deflating than the fact that I can't.
Day after day after day. Months on end. Years gone by. My mornings are not what they once were. Sometimes they are not at all. Mornings have given over to mourning. Mourning the person I once was. The life I was once living. The world I was once enthralled with.
Tuesday, March 9, 2010
Lyme Guideline Limbo
When last we spoke on the subject, I mentioned that the organization leading the charge against acknowledging and allowing treatment for patients with Lyme which doesn't go away after a short course of antibiotics is the Infectious Disease Society of America's (IDSA) Lyme Disease Guidelines Panel (LDGP.)
I also mentioned that this group was investigated by the Attorney General of Connecticut.
Before we continue on, we have to be clear about what the Attorney General was investigating. This was not an investigation of the science or the medicine. As reported:
Since I'm not versed in the intricacies of this area of law, I have to trust that the Attorney General and his people understood how they might apply to a non-profit, special interest society which is impacting the delivery of health care. You can see the use of antitrust language in their findings:
There is also collusion. The IDSA's group shared chairmen, authors and panelists with another, supposed independent, medical society who released Lyme Disease guidelines. Yet, never did the two organization reveal how related their groups were, creating the illusion that they reached their conclusions independently. Why the deceit?
Why indeed. What could motivate two not-for-profit organizations to do this? Here's an example of their self-defense:
The third thing to note is that their objection about the existence of persistent Lyme seems to be attached to their concern about the use of long-term antibiotics. If we decide that a persistent infection could be effectively treated with something else, would they still deny the existence of a persistent infection? I can certainly see the value to a robust exploration of the efficacy of long-term antibiotics. Hey, let's do some more research. Showing that one antibiotic didn't work, does not eliminate the possibility that another might. But even if antibiotics are not the answer, that's a different question than whether a persistent infection exists. So, I wish they would de-couple these two points.
Still, no matter their defense of their medical opinion, they are not defending their process. They are capitulating to the findings. This renders the opinions of the group suspicious.
And it still begs the question, "why?" Was it to protect the world from antibiotic overuse? Well, let's go back to the Attorney General's report:
Unfortunately, the motivation doesn't appear to be altruistic. While the not-for-profit organization that this panel is supposed to represent may not have questionable motivation, the individual members of the panel itself do. Money. Its so often about money. The panelists had financial interests in drug companies and Lyme tests? And had consulting arrangements with the very industry that is denying us treatment? These same people are testifying in court against other doctors? How are they credible?
How can we trust the work product of a group of people with such varied conflicts of interest? We can't. Therefore, the IDSA agreed to have a conflict-free panel created to review the guidelines. They agreed to a public process and voting procedure that would ensure that divergent research, clinical experience and scientific and medical opinion would be considered as they questioned whether the guidelines needed to be revised.
There have been questions along the way about whether the IDSA was meeting the spirit of the agreement in its openness. The supposedly public hearing did not allow press, the room was closed. Only after some public pressure did they agree to have the proceeding streamed online.
Worse, they violated the agreement about the voting procedure such that it would be almost impossible for the outcome to require a guidelines revision. I'll write a separate post about the details of that. The bottom line is that the review process is now hung in limbo. Meanwhile, the restrictive guidelines which are used by insurance companies to deny treatment are still in place.
I don't understand how such a suspect work product can be justifiably used. There are other medical societies which publish different guidelines. (see ILADS) Clearly there is no universal medical opinion. We know there is no definitive science. Yet, the IDSA, the group shown to have conflicts of interest, is allowed to monopolize control over the dispensation of treatment to hundreds of thousands of suffering people. How is this legal? And when does the Attorney General get to say, "Hey, we signed an agreement to avoid the conclusion of my investigation. You violated that agreement, so now I will press forward."? If his antitrust charges are proven true, are these criminal violations? I don't understand enough about the pertinent laws to assess that.
What I do know: its morally reprehensible. I don't know how these people sleep at night.
I also mentioned that this group was investigated by the Attorney General of Connecticut.
Before we continue on, we have to be clear about what the Attorney General was investigating. This was not an investigation of the science or the medicine. As reported:
Blumenthal thanked members his office who worked on the investigation -- Assistant Attorney General Thomas Ryan, former Assistant Attorney General Steven Rutstein and Paralegal Lorraine Measer under the direction of Assistant Attorney General Michael Cole, Chief of the Attorney General's Antitrust Department.That's right. The Antritrust Department. I'm no lawyer. I'm certainly no expert of antitrust laws, but I think I get the general idea. Antitrust laws are designed to make sure that business markets are not manipulated by unfair practices which eliminate the chance of fair competition. I do know that they originated in the US in response to monopolies in industries such as oil and transportation. You can read about the birth of those laws here.
Since I'm not versed in the intricacies of this area of law, I have to trust that the Attorney General and his people understood how they might apply to a non-profit, special interest society which is impacting the delivery of health care. You can see the use of antitrust language in their findings:
Blumenthal's findings include the following:What is clear here is that the Attorney General was not making a medical assessment. He was making a process assessment. That is, he was looking at whether the process through which the guidelines were published was a fair and open process where competitive ideas were given a fair chance to be considered. For instance, is the panel really going to consider all evidence when the chair is able to "handpick a likeminded panel"? What you can see in these findings is a process wherein there was a preconceived notion and the panelists were chosen based on an understanding that they would not challenge that notion.
- The IDSA failed to conduct a conflicts of interest review for any of the panelists prior to their appointment to the 2006 Lyme disease guideline panel;
- Subsequent disclosures demonstrate that several of the 2006 Lyme disease panelists had conflicts of interest;
- The IDSA failed to follow its own procedures for appointing the 2006 panel chairman and members, enabling the chairman, who held a bias regarding the existence of chronic Lyme, to handpick a likeminded panel without scrutiny by or formal approval of the IDSA's oversight committee;
- The IDSA's 2000 and 2006 Lyme disease panels refused to accept or meaningfully consider information regarding the existence of chronic Lyme disease, once removing a panelist from the 2000 panel who dissented from the group's position on chronic Lyme disease to achieve "consensus";
- The IDSA blocked appointment of scientists and physicians with divergent views on chronic Lyme who sought to serve on the 2006 guidelines panel by informing them that the panel was fully staffed, even though it was later expanded;
- The IDSA portrayed another medical association's Lyme disease guidelines as corroborating its own when it knew that the two panels shared several authors, including the chairmen of both groups, and were working on guidelines at the same time. In allowing its panelists to serve on both groups at the same time, IDSA violated its own conflicts of interest policy.
There is also collusion. The IDSA's group shared chairmen, authors and panelists with another, supposed independent, medical society who released Lyme Disease guidelines. Yet, never did the two organization reveal how related their groups were, creating the illusion that they reached their conclusions independently. Why the deceit?
Why indeed. What could motivate two not-for-profit organizations to do this? Here's an example of their self-defense:
"The Infectious Diseases Society says it's never been proven whether these patients still have Lyme disease or something else. The group continues to defend its standards, which say short-term antibiotics are effective for nearly all patients. Long-term antibiotics are unproven and potentially dangerous, because overuse of the drugs can lead to drug-resistant infections, the society says."This is in response to the antitrust charges. Note that they are not debunking the charges themselves. Also notable is that the IDSA doesn't require proof that Chronic Lyme doesn't exist, they require proof that it does. A patient is diagnosed with an illness, gets the proscribed treatment and is still suffering from all the same symptoms, does not test positive for anything else, and they can't prove it's not persistent Lyme, but they can deny them treatment.
The third thing to note is that their objection about the existence of persistent Lyme seems to be attached to their concern about the use of long-term antibiotics. If we decide that a persistent infection could be effectively treated with something else, would they still deny the existence of a persistent infection? I can certainly see the value to a robust exploration of the efficacy of long-term antibiotics. Hey, let's do some more research. Showing that one antibiotic didn't work, does not eliminate the possibility that another might. But even if antibiotics are not the answer, that's a different question than whether a persistent infection exists. So, I wish they would de-couple these two points.
Still, no matter their defense of their medical opinion, they are not defending their process. They are capitulating to the findings. This renders the opinions of the group suspicious.
And it still begs the question, "why?" Was it to protect the world from antibiotic overuse? Well, let's go back to the Attorney General's report:
"The IDSA's 2006 Lyme disease guideline panel undercut its credibility by allowing individuals with financial interests -- in drug companies, Lyme disease diagnostic tests, patents and consulting arrangements with insurance companies -- to exclude divergent medical evidence and opinion. In today's healthcare system, clinical practice guidelines have tremendous influence on the marketing of medical services and products, insurance reimbursements and treatment decisions. As a result, medical societies that publish such guidelines have a legal and moral duty to use exacting safeguards and scientific standards."
Unfortunately, the motivation doesn't appear to be altruistic. While the not-for-profit organization that this panel is supposed to represent may not have questionable motivation, the individual members of the panel itself do. Money. Its so often about money. The panelists had financial interests in drug companies and Lyme tests? And had consulting arrangements with the very industry that is denying us treatment? These same people are testifying in court against other doctors? How are they credible?
How can we trust the work product of a group of people with such varied conflicts of interest? We can't. Therefore, the IDSA agreed to have a conflict-free panel created to review the guidelines. They agreed to a public process and voting procedure that would ensure that divergent research, clinical experience and scientific and medical opinion would be considered as they questioned whether the guidelines needed to be revised.
There have been questions along the way about whether the IDSA was meeting the spirit of the agreement in its openness. The supposedly public hearing did not allow press, the room was closed. Only after some public pressure did they agree to have the proceeding streamed online.
Worse, they violated the agreement about the voting procedure such that it would be almost impossible for the outcome to require a guidelines revision. I'll write a separate post about the details of that. The bottom line is that the review process is now hung in limbo. Meanwhile, the restrictive guidelines which are used by insurance companies to deny treatment are still in place.
I don't understand how such a suspect work product can be justifiably used. There are other medical societies which publish different guidelines. (see ILADS) Clearly there is no universal medical opinion. We know there is no definitive science. Yet, the IDSA, the group shown to have conflicts of interest, is allowed to monopolize control over the dispensation of treatment to hundreds of thousands of suffering people. How is this legal? And when does the Attorney General get to say, "Hey, we signed an agreement to avoid the conclusion of my investigation. You violated that agreement, so now I will press forward."? If his antitrust charges are proven true, are these criminal violations? I don't understand enough about the pertinent laws to assess that.
What I do know: its morally reprehensible. I don't know how these people sleep at night.
Monday, March 1, 2010
Burden of Proof
While I'm writing the next installment about the IDSA guidelines review process, I've had a thought.
I was engaged in a debate about the validity of Chronic Lyme Disease recently. It was frustrating. I avoid these discussions because they don't get anywhere and there is something about them that I find very flawed. It has taken me a while to pinpoint it. I think I have done, though.
The IDSA has set the standard for how we define, test for and treat Lyme Disease. They claim there is no such thing as Neurologic Lyme or Persistent Lyme or whatever you want to call it. One of their representatives is a vocal advocate for labeling any ongoing symptoms after a short course of antibiotics as a psychosomatic illness. Based on IDSA authority, doctors across the country are told that they cannot treat a patient for more than 4 weeks. If they try, they are flagged by insurance companies and their licenses are threatened. Members of the IDSA often appear at Medical Board hearings to testify against their fellow doctors who try to treat patients. So, patients are left to languish.
In every debate about whether the longer-term illness that people are experiencing is "real" or not, those who want to believe in the IDSA guidelines insist that those who don't must prove that Chronic Lyme is real. Any attempt to discuss the matter devolves into persistent demands that you reference scientific studies which prove to their satisfaction that Lyme is persistent.
Of course, those of us who are just patients, don't have the skill set nor the resources to know all the studies that may or may not have been done. And, so, we are told we have no place at the table. The guidelines supporters believe they have rightfully ended the debate.
Here's what bothers me: Where is the science that proves beyond all doubt that persistence is not possible? Where is the science that proves that long-term treatment is never helpful? Where is the science that proves that these patients suffer from a psychosomatic disorder?
It seems to me that if you are going to override what the clinical doctor, who sees the patient, is asserting that the patient needs and, by doing so, you are leaving hundreds of thousands of people to suffer and die, the burden of proof is on you. Just because you haven't figured out the mechanism of the illness or what might be the best course of treatment, does not mean that you have the right to deny doctors and their patients the ability to try and figure it out the best they can right now.
That burden has not been met.
So, from now on, I am going to insist in any debate about whether patients need treatment for their ailment that you prove beyond a doubt that they don't. I refuse to chase the red herring of having to prove that they do.
Clearly, the science is limited, thus far. Fund the research. Fund it with monies that do not come with conflicts of interest. Make both the process and the results of all the studies public. Until you do, stop being the de facto law over the private practices of other doctors. Get out of my way and let me have some chance, any chance, at recovery.
I was engaged in a debate about the validity of Chronic Lyme Disease recently. It was frustrating. I avoid these discussions because they don't get anywhere and there is something about them that I find very flawed. It has taken me a while to pinpoint it. I think I have done, though.
The IDSA has set the standard for how we define, test for and treat Lyme Disease. They claim there is no such thing as Neurologic Lyme or Persistent Lyme or whatever you want to call it. One of their representatives is a vocal advocate for labeling any ongoing symptoms after a short course of antibiotics as a psychosomatic illness. Based on IDSA authority, doctors across the country are told that they cannot treat a patient for more than 4 weeks. If they try, they are flagged by insurance companies and their licenses are threatened. Members of the IDSA often appear at Medical Board hearings to testify against their fellow doctors who try to treat patients. So, patients are left to languish.
In every debate about whether the longer-term illness that people are experiencing is "real" or not, those who want to believe in the IDSA guidelines insist that those who don't must prove that Chronic Lyme is real. Any attempt to discuss the matter devolves into persistent demands that you reference scientific studies which prove to their satisfaction that Lyme is persistent.
Of course, those of us who are just patients, don't have the skill set nor the resources to know all the studies that may or may not have been done. And, so, we are told we have no place at the table. The guidelines supporters believe they have rightfully ended the debate.
Here's what bothers me: Where is the science that proves beyond all doubt that persistence is not possible? Where is the science that proves that long-term treatment is never helpful? Where is the science that proves that these patients suffer from a psychosomatic disorder?
It seems to me that if you are going to override what the clinical doctor, who sees the patient, is asserting that the patient needs and, by doing so, you are leaving hundreds of thousands of people to suffer and die, the burden of proof is on you. Just because you haven't figured out the mechanism of the illness or what might be the best course of treatment, does not mean that you have the right to deny doctors and their patients the ability to try and figure it out the best they can right now.
That burden has not been met.
So, from now on, I am going to insist in any debate about whether patients need treatment for their ailment that you prove beyond a doubt that they don't. I refuse to chase the red herring of having to prove that they do.
Clearly, the science is limited, thus far. Fund the research. Fund it with monies that do not come with conflicts of interest. Make both the process and the results of all the studies public. Until you do, stop being the de facto law over the private practices of other doctors. Get out of my way and let me have some chance, any chance, at recovery.
Saturday, February 27, 2010
Testing, Testing, Wrong.
I'm being put through a new battery of tests by my new neurologist. Some of them are tests I've done before and some are new. Its an intense 3 weeks. I'm happy to have all these tests done if it moves the process along and we can figure out how to get treatment for me so that I can recover my life.
However, I find some of the tests problematic. I don't understand how the medical world figures out anything, sometimes. Here is a short list of the inanity of the testing protocols I've faced:
However, I find some of the tests problematic. I don't understand how the medical world figures out anything, sometimes. Here is a short list of the inanity of the testing protocols I've faced:
- I have complained for years that my hearing has become over-sensitive. Air conditioning systems are a constant tidal wave roaring through my head. I can hear small sounds hundreds of feet away and they grate on my brain. Sharp sounds are just that: piercingly painful. The world is a heavy metal concert assaulting my head every day. It is the single symptom for which I would take my life if I were so inclined. I have only had one doctor even note my complaint about hearing.
When she did, I was sent for hearing exam. An exam to test for hearing loss. Hey, guess what? I don't have any hearing loss! Yet, this is the screening test for referring you to a hearing specialist. Even though hyper-acusis is a known hearing condition, in our health care system, controlled by insurance companies, one must fail a hearing loss test to be referred to an ear doc. Testing, testing, wrong.
- I live with tingling/burning/numbness/sharp pains in my extremities. For the most part this is just annoying and distracting. I've learned to move through the pain and the other sensations have become part of the white noise of my internal self. It does bring functional issues. I don't feel terrain properly under my feet, so I can be klutzy, even injure myself. I also have tremors and those cause functional issues. Sometimes I can't write or hold a cup or do myriad things that require fine motor control. At this point, since I'm used to having pain which is not a real "injury", my brain doesn't react to the pain in my feet the same way it used to. What this means is that I've actually injured my feet or ankles without realizing it. Not good. Mostly, though, these neuropathies are an indicator that something is going very wrong in my nervous system.
So, I'm sent for an EMG, or nerve conduction exam. The exam took more than twice as long as expected and, of course, I asked why. "Because we're getting the lowest possible reading in the normal scale on one side and the highest possible normal reading on the other side. We never seen anything like this before, so we're rechecking to make sure we're getting the right readings. This is very abnormal. But, both readings are in the normal range, so we're reporting it as normal." With that, there is no more consideration of my neuropathies. Testing, testing, wrong.
- Yesterday, I went for an Autonomic Nervous System test, aka Tilt Table Testing. The docs have determined that there is something wrong with my autonomic system because I have body temperature control issues, heart palpitations, unexpected shortness of breath, sudden weakness, high IgG levels without having Celiac Disease and I suddenly became allergic to every single thing I've been tested for. The one test for whether my autonomic system is in disarry is apparently this Tilt Table Testing.
In this test, they hook you up to pulse monitors, blood pressure monitors and breathing monitors. You lie down and get relaxed on a table and they take baseline measurements. My resting heart rate is 50. Then they have you do a breathing exercise. Basically, deep breathing: "breathe in as deep as you can for 5 seconds, then let the breath out over a 5 second period." Meditation anyone? I do a lot of it. This kind of breathing is calming for me. I'm not sure what they're measuring with this. But then, they strap you onto the table and tilt you up to a not-quite-vertical position, with one arm propped out parallel to your heart level. It's a stress position. Its fairly uncomfortable. My wrist and elbow on the propped arm were in pain, my knees and feet were in pain. I was physically uncomfortable. What they're looking to do here is to stress the autonomic system and see if the heart rate/breathing/blood pressure dynamic gets out of whack. Only one problem: I don't necessarily get stressed by physical discomfort. I can breathe through it. I used to be a competitive athlete. I performed in state aerobics competition with an ankle that I had sprained just 2 day earlier. I broke my wrist about 5 years ago, walked to my neighbor's house and asked if they would sever me dinner before taking me to the emergency room because I knew it would be a long wait. I was very calm. Its just something I've learned to manage. I can acknowledge pain so that it can be attended to without becoming stressed. Pain is temporary.
So, if they were trying to create a stress reaction in my body, physical discomfort was not the way to do it.
Meanwhile, my heart rate peaked at about 80. Now, that's a 60% increase over my resting heart rate. If anybody else's heart rate had jumped 60% instantaneously, it would have been noted as a stress reaction. Not mine, because 80 is a normal resting heart rate for many people and it is not considered to be stressing the heart. So, it will be recorded as "normal". My systemic dysfunctions are not going be validated. I'm penalized for starting at a much healthier baseline. Testing, testing, wrong.
Friday, February 26, 2010
One Strand at a Time
After beginning to explain the dysfunctional system which leads to Lyme patients going untreated, I felt a little overwhelmed by all the strands of this diabolical web. I had hoped to post a follow-up this week, but became a little paralyzed by the breadth and depth of the issues, which include but are not limited to:
There are so many threads in this web. Some of them, when seen by themselves, may seem innouous. Others are problematic enough on their own to make you wonder how any reasonable human being could have thought that it served any public good to put it in place. Still, its not until you start to see how all the pieces fit together that you see the infuriating nature of it. Each strand strengthens the diabolical web, while the individuals twisting their one strand can convince themselves that they are only doing what they are required to do. They can ignore how their works fit into the overall trap and maintain an internal feeling of plausible deniability when it comes to culpability.
Of course, its when you are sick and trying to navigate this system that you are most likely to have the light hit the web at just the right angle for you to see it. When you have the least inner personal resource to fight the system in order to get what you need.
I write this post today as a sort of check list. To help me remember some of the many threads that need to be explored in order to shine that light on the web. I'll simply have to tackle one thing at a time and see if I can manage to show how they are tied together along the way. For Monday, I'll update the story on the IDSA and what has happened since they signed an agreement with the CT State Attorney General to review their guidelines. The case of the IDSA, their conflicts of interest, their connetions to the medial establishment, their guidelines and how they get used is a perfect demonstration of the trap created by the web. To write about it though, I must try to pick little chunks at a time, as it becomes a tome faster than the vibrations of the prey reach across the web to the spider.
Who is the spider? Well, I think we are. Every one us. We have, every step of the way, refused to revolt against the system we've watched being built over decades. More than a century, even. Because while the medical system has been radically altered with laws created in the last 50 or so years, the foundation for it all goes back to the laws that gave corporations "personhood". There are so many profound social dysfunctions that spring from that one topic. But, it seems to be getting way beyond a discussion about Lyme Disease, doesn't it? What if there is no way to get solid research available to the public and to force insurance companies to let doctors determine the best treatment for their patients without tackling these foundational issues? The more I learn about the obstacles to getting treatment for Lyme Disease and any ensuing health conditions, the more I run into these questions. So, my blog will have to traverse the ground of issues specific to Lyme Disease, such as managing symptoms, getting the right tests, learning about treatment options, etc, as well as, bigger public policy questions of a health care system that serves the people well, including the political and legal obstacles to shifting towards something compassionate and sustainable. I hope you'll bear with me, as I'm sure it will be a meandering amble.
- The Dole-Bayh Act of 1981
- Insurance Industry Exemption to Federal Anti-Trust Laws
- ERISA 514 (one clause in a huge federal bill that exempts Insurance companies from state laws)
- monied interest in developing vaccines, treatments, tests, etc.
- Insurance industry practice of denying claims as a matter of course in order to save money
- the confusing chaos around an emerging disease
- the closed-loop medical establishment (with repercussions from doctors protecting one another from outside scrutiny to the controlled distribution of research money)
- the lack of any independent, official body advocating for patient well-being as the number one priority in health care dispensation
- the impacts of a socio-political-economic system that puts corporate income at the top of its hierarchy of needs
- a medical science philosophy where a patient's symptoms aren't considered real until someone can devise a test to verify said symptoms.
There are so many threads in this web. Some of them, when seen by themselves, may seem innouous. Others are problematic enough on their own to make you wonder how any reasonable human being could have thought that it served any public good to put it in place. Still, its not until you start to see how all the pieces fit together that you see the infuriating nature of it. Each strand strengthens the diabolical web, while the individuals twisting their one strand can convince themselves that they are only doing what they are required to do. They can ignore how their works fit into the overall trap and maintain an internal feeling of plausible deniability when it comes to culpability.
Of course, its when you are sick and trying to navigate this system that you are most likely to have the light hit the web at just the right angle for you to see it. When you have the least inner personal resource to fight the system in order to get what you need.
I write this post today as a sort of check list. To help me remember some of the many threads that need to be explored in order to shine that light on the web. I'll simply have to tackle one thing at a time and see if I can manage to show how they are tied together along the way. For Monday, I'll update the story on the IDSA and what has happened since they signed an agreement with the CT State Attorney General to review their guidelines. The case of the IDSA, their conflicts of interest, their connetions to the medial establishment, their guidelines and how they get used is a perfect demonstration of the trap created by the web. To write about it though, I must try to pick little chunks at a time, as it becomes a tome faster than the vibrations of the prey reach across the web to the spider.
Who is the spider? Well, I think we are. Every one us. We have, every step of the way, refused to revolt against the system we've watched being built over decades. More than a century, even. Because while the medical system has been radically altered with laws created in the last 50 or so years, the foundation for it all goes back to the laws that gave corporations "personhood". There are so many profound social dysfunctions that spring from that one topic. But, it seems to be getting way beyond a discussion about Lyme Disease, doesn't it? What if there is no way to get solid research available to the public and to force insurance companies to let doctors determine the best treatment for their patients without tackling these foundational issues? The more I learn about the obstacles to getting treatment for Lyme Disease and any ensuing health conditions, the more I run into these questions. So, my blog will have to traverse the ground of issues specific to Lyme Disease, such as managing symptoms, getting the right tests, learning about treatment options, etc, as well as, bigger public policy questions of a health care system that serves the people well, including the political and legal obstacles to shifting towards something compassionate and sustainable. I hope you'll bear with me, as I'm sure it will be a meandering amble.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
